With the 9j +35, you need to just roll the middle tab of the front fenders. You can run a +45, but you camber needs to be very very conservative because clearance will be an issue on the front struts.
I'm on a +22 with a 255 up front on stock fenders. They're pulled, but they're stock. You can safely run a 9j with a +35.
This is my +35 setup with 255/40/17 up front. It fit, but JUST barely. As I said early — I'd recommend running a square 235 all the way around if it's your daily driver and you're looking for a rotatable setup. Let me know if you have any more questions.